Helm vs Deputy: tour operations vs shift scheduling
Deputy is a powerful shift scheduling tool used across hospitality. Tour operations have different requirements — OTA sync, guide qualifications, and operational intelligence. Here's how the two approaches compare.
Helm is tour operations software — scheduling, OTA sync, and team coordination in one platform.
0
tour-specific features in Deputy
300K+
workplaces using Deputy globally
Deputy.com
100%
of Helm features built for tour operations
| Feature | Helm | Deputy |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose-built for tour operations | ||
| OTA / booking platform integration | ||
| Guide qualification matching | ||
| Last-minute change cascading | ||
| AI-powered labor forecasting | ||
| Shift-based scheduling | ||
| Payroll integration | ||
| Google Calendar sync | ||
| Mobile app for workers | ||
| Free plan | Yes (2 seats) | No |
The bottom line
Deputy is excellent for industries where scheduling is about filling shifts — restaurants, retail, healthcare. Tour operations aren't shift-based. Every tour is a unique event with specific requirements, and the 'shift' changes every time a new booking comes in from an OTA. Helm understands tours, guides, and bookings. Deputy understands shifts and employees. Choose the tool that speaks your language.
Why shift scheduling doesn't work for tour operations
Deputy has built a strong reputation in hospitality and retail scheduling. With AI-powered demand forecasting and payroll integrations, it's a sophisticated workforce tool. But the sophistication is aimed at the wrong problem when it comes to tour operations.
In a restaurant, a shift is a shift. You need 3 waiters from 11 AM to 3 PM, and any qualified waiter can fill the slot. In tour operations, every 'shift' is unique: this tour needs a French-speaking guide who knows the Louvre, that tour needs a certified climbing instructor who's done the Via Ferrata route at least 10 times. Deputy can tell you who's free at 2 PM. It can't tell you who's qualified for the 2 PM canyon tour.
The fundamental mismatch is data flow. Deputy gets its scheduling data from your manual input or POS system. Helm gets it from your OTAs — Bókun, Viator, GetYourGuide. When a tourist in Japan books a Paris walking tour for tomorrow through Viator at midnight, Helm knows about it and has it ready for scheduling by morning. Deputy doesn't even know it happened.
Tour operators who've tried Deputy typically describe the same experience: it works for basic time-slot scheduling, but they still need spreadsheets for the tour-specific details — language requirements, guide qualifications, customer headcounts, meeting points. Helm eliminates that second layer by treating tours as the primary unit of scheduling, not time slots.
Stop managing your tours from a spreadsheet and a group chat—there's a better way.
Helm replaces the patchwork of tools tour operators rely on with one purpose-built platform for everything that happens after a booking.
Try Helm for free
Frequently asked questions
Related pages
Ready to replace the patchwork?
Start for free with 2 team seats. No credit card required.